Skip to content

What is the best power system for sustainable aviation?

  • by
Aurata Sustainable Aviation

As the aviation industry strives for greener solutions, selecting the best power system for sustainable aviation is a key challenge. Let’s explore three zero carbon options – batteries, hydrogen fuel cells, and hydrogen gas turbines – and how they measure up in terms of energy density, efficiency, and sustainability.

Power System Requirements in Aviation

The aviation sector is highly sensitive to the energy and power density of the available technology. For sustainable aviation, energy sources must be carbon-neutral, and the embodied energy of the power systems themselves must be taken into account.

Comparing Power Systems for Sustainable Aviation

While Sustainable Aviation Fuels (SAF) are one option, concerns over the scalability and sustainability of feedstocks at large volumes prompt this article to focus on zero-carbon energy sources like batteries and hydrogen. Despite the relatively low efficiency of “green” hydrogen generation and use, it remains a viable contender in the pursuit of sustainability. The sustainability of battery production also depends on the methods and locations of raw material extraction together with battery recycling techniquies.

Given the focus on zero-carbon solutions, we’ll explore the potential of batteries, hydrogen fuel cells, and hydrogen gas turbines –keeping in mind their respective strengths and limitations when it comes to sustainable aviation.

  • Volumetric Energy Density: Current lithium-ion batteries have a low volumetric energy density, about one-tenth of aviation fuel and half that of liquid hydrogen when considering Tank-To-Wake (TTWa) efficiency losses. It is similar to compressed gaseous hydrogen.
  • Gravimetric Energy Density: Even more challenging is the poor gravimetric energy density of batteries. A typical lithium-ion battery for TTWa delivers only a twenty-fifth of the energy density of aviation fuel, or a fifth of compressed hydrogen at 350 bar, including storage tanks.
  • Applications: Due to these limitations, battery technology is primarily suitable for short-range drones and eVTOL (electric vertical take-off and landing) aircraft. Without major advances in energy density, batteries are best reserved for short-range, lightweight aviation applications.

Hydrogen fuel cells are emerging as a promising alternative to batteries in sustainable aviation.

  • Higher Gravimetric Energy Density: Fuel cells offer a much higher gravimetric energy density compared to batteries, making them suitable for longer-range applications.
  • Higher Utilization Time: They also allow for longer operational hours and faster refuelling compared to batteries.
  • Electric Propulsion: Unlike hydrogen gas turbines, fuel cells are directly electric, which simplifies hybridization with other power systems.

Fuel cell technology is currently more suitable for small-scale aviation, such as low-volume aircraft used in niche applications. However, they often require bespoke solutions tailored to specific aircraft designs, especially for the balance of plant. This can enable higher efficiency, but is a trade off with increasing costs and development time.

Hydrogen gas turbines, particularly hydrogen turbofans and turboprops, are another option for sustainable aviation. This is based on more proven propulsion technology, especially in terms of reliability and maintenance, and a more iterative engineering development compared to the other options.

However, they face challenges in terms of efficiency and are more complex to integrate into hybrid-electric systems compared to fuel cells. But, if only thrust for propulsion is required a hydrogen gas turbine is far superior in terms of power density and packaging than a fuel cell with a separate motor.

The Future of Sustainable Aviation Power Systems

Proton Exchange Membrane (PEM) fuel cells are well-suited to transportation, including aviation, due to their high efficiency, scalability and high gravimetric power density. High-Temperature PEM (HT PEM) fuel cells can further increase efficiency, potentially making them a more attractive option for aircraft in the future.

As technology continues to improve, we may see significant advances in the energy density of batteries, the mass of hydrogen storage tanks, and the power density of fuel cell systems over the next decade. These innovations could shift the competitiveness of these technologies, and enabling their use in larger, longer-range aircraft.

Conclusion

When it comes to sustainable aviation, no single power system offers a perfect solution. Batteries are best suited for short-range, lightweight applications like drones and eVTOL taxis, while hydrogen fuel cells offer higher energy density and longer operation times for small-scale aviation. Hydrogen gas turbines could play a role in larger aircraft where hybrid-electric solutions are less suited to the operating profile.

As technology evolves, the race to power the future of aviation sustainably will continue, with fuel cells, batteries, and hydrogen gas turbines all playing a part in reducing carbon emissions in the skies.

This is the second in a general interest series of articles. Aurata will be presenting more technical depth on fuel cell systems at the Electric & Hybrid Aerospace Technology Symposium (EHATS) in Frankfurt on 30 & 31 October 2024. For tickets see www.electricandhybridaerospacetechnology.com/en/.

Do you have a question about energy or thermal management, particularly related to battery or fuel cell systems? If so, please send your questions to info@auratatech.com or get in touch with us on LinkedIn.

Privacy Overview

Cookies are used so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

Our privacy policy is available at https://auratatech.com/privacy-policy/